Sharia Dispute Resolution: Non-Muslims Seek Justice In Islamic Courts

Sharia Dispute Resolution: Non-Muslims Seek Justice In Islamic Courts

On Tuesday, The Times reported that increasing numbers of non-Muslims are turning to
Sharia courts to resolve civil disputes.  The Muslim Arbitration Tribunal claims as many as 5% of its cases
involve non-Muslims who use the courts because they are “less cumbersome and
more informal than the English legal system.”

Turns out 5% equates to a meagre 20 cases this year.  Still, the story does
raise big legal questions:  First, concerning the validity of religious
tribunals, whose rulings are legally binding under the Arbitration Act (provided
the parties agree to that condition before arbitration begins).  Second,
regarding state entanglement with religion, since it falls on the state to
enforce the Sharia rulings should a party failure to comply with one.  And,
third, respecting resolution of disputes outside the courtroom.

In the hope of demystifying Alternative Dispute Resolution (“ADR”), here are 10
things everyone ought to know:

1. What is ADR?

ADR is a catch-all term used to describe different methods to resolve legal
disputes outside of court.

2. How do ADR schemes work?

Arbitration:  An impartial and independent third
party decides how to resolve the dispute.  In most cases, the arbitrator’s
decision is binding and cannot be challenged in court.  The
arbitrator’s decision must remain secret unless the parties agree otherwise. 
The cost varies:  arbitration is free to employers and employees; schemes are either free or require payment of a registration
fee, which is refunded if a party is successful; other arbitration schemes can
be expensive, but it depends on the nature and complexity of the dispute.

Adjudication:  Similar to arbitration, but usually
not binding on the person making the complaint.  Most adjudication
schemes are free to consumers.

Mediation/Conciliation:  An impartial
and independent mediator or conciliator helps the parties negotiate a resolution
to the dispute.  If the parties do not want to negotiate in person, a mediator
may act as go-between.  Everything that occurs during mediation or conciliation
remains confidential and cannot be used in a later court hearing.  The cost
varies: in some instances (usually conciliation), it is free; in others, it can
get expensive – again, everything depends on the nature and complexity of the
dispute.

Negotiation:  The simplest form of ADR.  Negotiations
may be held with or without prejudice; the latter prevents evidence of
negotiations being used in court.

Ombudsmen:  Ombudsmen investigate and resolve
complaints about public and private organisations.  Members of the British and
Irish Ombudsman Association are guaranteed to be independent and impartial from
the organisations they investigate.  Most ombudsmen expect you to exhaust an
organisation’s internal complaints procedure before seeking help.  Most
ombudsmen decisions are not legally binding on the complainant.  All
ombudsman schemes are free. 

3. Is ADR binding or non-binding?

It depends on the form of ADR used.  Generally, arbitration is binding on
both parties to the dispute; mediation, conciliation, and negotiation are
non-binding; and adjudication and ombudsmen schemes do not bind the complainant,
but will be binding on the other side.

4. If I use ADR, do I need a solicitor?

Just as you would seek advice when going to court, you should in most cases
seek advice when choosing and pursuing ADR.

5. Who adjudicates ADR?

Again, this depends on the form of ADR used.  See above.

6. Where does ADR take place?

Usually a neutral place acceptable to all parties involved in the
dispute.

7. How much does ADR cost?

Many ADR schemes are free, but some are not.  It all depends on your
circumstances and the nature of the dispute.  See pages 16-17 of the  published by the Community Legal
Service.

8. How long does ADR take to complete?

Each case is different and it depends on the type of ADR you use.  But,
generally disputes are resolved faster using ADR than in the courtroom.

9. Is ADR confidential?

Generally, yes.

10. How do I decide whether to use ADR and which type should I
choose?

Everyone’s situation is different, so you should discuss this with a
solicitor.  And, as a starting point, read pages 3-6 of the published by the Community Legal
Service. 

** Additional Information & Advice **

You can obtain further information about ADR on .

Depending on the circumstances of your case, however, it may be a good idea
to speak with a solicitor who specialises on ADR.  You can be  in your area
for free via solicitor matching services, which can also help you to understand
the best course of action for your situation and whether you are ready to hire a
solicitor.